I remember life before the Internet very well, but whether we were happier?
I cannot say.
I have learned, certainly, that there are limits on how much happiness the Internet can bring you. I’ve also learned that sometimes when you cannot find friends in your own area, you need to cast a wider net. Life before the Internet has been idealized as utopia, but it brought the smartest minds in the firmament together.
That’s been a long time gripe of people my age, because In the Beginning,™ only smart & truly dedicated people were on it. This is not because America Online didn’t exist. In those days, most computers did not come with modems and you had to get that working, first. If you managed to install your modem correctly, then the install software for AOL, CompuServe, and a few other smaller players could get you up and running fast…. but even then, you were running a modified version of the Internet; none of those companies told you that once you were connected, you could download Netscape Navigator or use Internet Explorer to get out of the curated version of the Internet those companies presented.
People my age were the first to go through this ultimate transition from offline to on. We’ve seen every iteration culturally, because of course the military had ARPANET to be able to talk to each other years before…. but we were the last generation to go from completely analog (free) to not being able to leave the house without some sort of device (tethered). Most children do not have that now, because even if children aren’t allowed a cell phone, they’re generally allowed a wi-fi device and they are sometimes given away by their schools.
In my fifth grade classroom, I could not have known that this was the case while I was playing The Oregon Trail. I could not have known that the computer was the red flag to all of this, that people would take desktop computing so seriously that they made an entire society around your computer in your pocket. And in fact, the newest Samsung devices are designed to be both your desktop and your phone using the “Dex” interface. Android is designed to be your one stop shop for all computing needs because God forbid you go a single moment without your electronic babysitter.
Electronic babysitters crept up.
First it was our beepers. Then it was our cell phones. Then it was our cell phones with access to our e-mail and a terrible web browser. Then it was smart phones. Now, it’s smart phones that can connect to your computer monitor and become a desktop.
There is no more room in our society for “dead zones,” which for me used to mean going on hikes in the Columbia River Gorge where my phone and GPS were no use. Not having access to those things doesn’t generally make one panic. It makes everyone around you panic. In that way, I do miss life before the Internet. People had more tolerance for it taking a half hour to get a call back. Now, it is expected that you are available for everyone’s every need all of the time.
The flip side is that I knew I was queer when I was 10 years old in Texas, so by the time America Online rolled around, I was ready for it. I didn’t have queer friends where I lived, but I had them in lots of other countries. Before I had the Internet, I was indescribably lonely. It wasn’t the echo chamber you see now, because Internet Relay Chat and America Online were not curated so that you only saw the news your side of the Congressional aisle wanted you to see. The schism took years to complete. It was easier to get along with everyone when we all had differences of opinion on funding, not whether only white, straight, cis, male people deserved to be American. White, cis, straight women are encouraged to be people as long as they understand they are nothing more than their husband’s pets.
Yesterday (Memorial Day), the current American society pissed on the graves of everyone who fought to eradicate fascism during WWII while the rest of the world scratched their heads at our “unique” antics (read: insane). That would not have happened if the disinformation campaign by Russia had not been running for many years. It’s all connected. Ignorance is bliss in this case. Not only can your device create a complete profile of your likes and dislikes, the information is forwarded to the government. Notice I didn’t say “our government.” You actually don’t know which one is mining your data, which is another reason to long for 1985. Sometimes, it’s the good guys, like CIA and NSA.
I may be rancid butter, but at least I’m on your side of the bread. -Jim Mattox
Sometimes it’s our collective enemies, like Russia and China. The American president has oft been accused of cozying up to them because he wants that kind of authoritative power… and he’s doing his best to get it while throwing the rest of us under the bus. Ukraine has been put in an impossible situation, Finland and Poland are preparing to be next. However, it is hard to get the average American to consider the Ukrainians, Poles, and Finns. It is hard to get the average American to care about more than the price of eggs, especially when they will believe a lie easier than the truth. What is more plausible? That the American president can wave a magic wand and bring down the price of anything, or that prices fluctuate and it has very little to do with the current president at all? Generally, when we are talking about the economy, we need to look at who was the president eight to 12 years back.
Democrats spend time cleaning up after ideas like Reaganomics, but the trickle down theory hangs on like a bad penny.
Poor people are still waiting for Reagan’s theory to work, and he’s been dead for years.
The gaslighting put forth by the Republican party is that it will, if given long enough. Meanwhile, greed envelops the nation and somehow the cup which is supposed to overflow keeps getting larger to accommodate more wealth. That message was the predominant one before the advent of the Internet, because Reagan’s “Morning in America” was all the rage. In this way, life has not changed one bit. Instead of Michael Deaver (known as “The Wizard of Oz” for the packaging of news content on the administration and sending it straight to the station to make Reagan look competent) and his bag of tricks, we have an entire party, along with its own news channel, trying to tell us there’s nothing to see here. It’s not a different message. It’s just a different scale. You’ll all be richer and better off if the greed of the billionaires is allowed to run unchecked.
Instead of three television stations, though, we have social media and a 24 hour news cycle….. along with foreign actors that are willing to help spread that message because it brings about more destruction in the unity of the country. There is no way to get a break from your news being tailored to you so that you only believe what you’re allowed to see.
The only answer is to unplug.



