When I read your words, what struck me wasn’t the specifics but the familiar shape of the dynamic between us — the way two people can live inside the same story and still come away with completely different interpretations of what happened. It brought back the old feeling of being misread, of having my intentions translated into something I never meant, of watching a narrative form around me that I didn’t recognize as my own.
It reminded me of the years when I kept trying to explain myself more clearly, hoping that if I just found the right phrasing, the right tone, the right angle, you would finally see that I wasn’t punishing you. I was trying to tell the truth of my experience. I was trying to meet you in the middle. I was trying to stop carrying the weight of misunderstandings that didn’t belong to me.
Reading your message, I felt the old ache of being cast in a role I never agreed to play. The sense that my honesty was being interpreted as hostility. The sense that my attempts to name what hurt were being reframed as attacks. The sense that you were defending yourself against a version of me that only existed in your mind.
But I also felt something new — something steadier. I could see the pattern without getting pulled into it. I could feel the history without drowning in it. I could love you without accepting the story you were trying to hand me.
What I realized, sitting with your words, is that I can forgive you. I can care about you. I can even imagine rebuilding something with you someday. But I can’t pretend everything is fine when it isn’t. I can’t smooth over the cracks just because the truth is uncomfortable. I can’t carry both sides of the relationship by myself.
I’ve spent a long time trying to understand why our conflicts happened, and the answer is simple: we were living in different emotional rooms. I was writing from a place of vulnerability, and you were reading from a place of fear. I was trying to connect, and you were trying to protect yourself. Neither of us were wrong, but the mismatch created a kind of static that neither of us knew how to clear.
You told me once that we are called to love our siblings, but we aren’t called to like them all the time. It’s exactly the way I feel about you. I don’t always like the way you disappear into silence. I don’t always like the way you assume the worst of me. I don’t always like the way you retreat instead of speaking from the inside of your own experience.
Still, none of that erases the affection. None of it erases the history. None of it erases the part of me that wants things to be better between us.
I’m writing this now because my life is expanding in ways that feel good and grounded, and I want you to know where I am. I’ll be spending more time in your area soon, and if you want to show up, you can. If you don’t, that’s okay too. I’m not asking for anything except that you don’t make things harder than they need to be.
I don’t have to love every part of this.
I just have to live it.
Scored by Copilot. Conducted by Leslie Lanagan.
Stories That Are All True 