The Theatre of Work: Why Autistic People Get Hired but Struggle to Stay

Most people think autistic adults struggle in the workplace because they can’t get hired. That’s not actually the problem. Autistic people do get hired — often because their résumés are strong, their skills are undeniable, and their interviews go well enough to get them through the door. The real issue is what happens after they’re hired. The modern office is built on a set of unwritten rules, social rituals, and performance expectations that have nothing to do with the job itself. And those expectations collide directly with autistic neurology in ways that are invisible to most people but devastatingly real for the people living inside them.

The core problem is simple: the workplace is a theatre, and autistic people are not actors. They’re builders, thinkers, analysts, designers, problem‑solvers — but the office rewards performance over competence, choreography over clarity, and social fluency over actual output. Once you understand that, everything else snaps into place.

The theatre of work begins with the idea that professionalism is something you perform. Eye contact becomes a moral test. A handshake becomes a character evaluation. Small talk becomes a measure of “culture fit.” None of these things are job skills, but they’re treated as if they are. And this is where autistic people start getting misread long before their actual work is ever evaluated.

Take eye contact. In the theatre of work, eye contact is treated as evidence of confidence, honesty, engagement, and leadership potential. But for many autistic people, eye contact is overwhelming, distracting, or even painful. They look away to think. They look away to listen. They look away to regulate. But the workplace interprets that as evasive, cold, or untrustworthy. The system mistakes regulation for disrespect, and the person is judged on a behavior that has nothing to do with their competence.

Touch is another compulsory ritual. Handshakes, high‑fives, fist bumps — none of these gestures are necessary for doing the job. They’re props in the performance of professionalism. But many autistic people have sensory sensitivities that make touch uncomfortable or dysregulating. No one wants to walk into an interview and say, “I’m autistic and I don’t like being touched.” It would give the interviewer context, but disclosure is risky. So autistic people force themselves through the ritual, even when it costs them cognitive bandwidth they need for the actual conversation. And if they don’t comply, they’re labeled rude or aloof. The system punishes the boundary, not the behavior.

Then there’s auditory processing disorder, which is far more common among autistic adults than most people realize. APD doesn’t mean someone can’t hear. It means they can’t decode speech at the speed it’s delivered — especially in chaotic environments. And modern meetings are chaos. People talk over each other. Ideas bounce around rapidly. Tone and implication carry more weight than the actual words. For someone with APD, this is a neurological bottleneck. They may leave a meeting thinking they caught half of it, then understand everything an hour later once the noise stops and their brain can replay, sort, and synthesize. Autistic cognition is deep, not instant. But the theatre of work rewards instant reactions, not accurate ones. The person who speaks first is seen as engaged. The person who processes quietly is seen as passive. The system punishes latency, not ability.

Overwhelm is another invisible fault line. When autistic adults experience what’s often called a “meltdown,” it’s rarely dramatic. It’s not screaming or throwing things. It’s going quiet. It’s losing words. It’s shutting down. It’s needing to step away. But the theatre of work only recognizes visible emotion. Quiet overwhelm reads as disengaged, unmotivated, or “checked out.” There is no lenience for internal overload. If you can’t perform “fine,” the system doesn’t know what to do with you.

And because disclosure is unsafe, autistic people mask. They force eye contact. They tolerate touch. They mimic tone. They rehearse scripts. They manually track social cues that neurotypical people process automatically. Masking is not “fitting in.” It’s manual labor. It’s running a second operating system in the background just to appear normal. It’s cognitively expensive, exhausting, and unsustainable. And when the mask inevitably slips — because no one can maintain that level of performance forever — the person is labeled inconsistent, unprofessional, or unreliable.

This is the moment when autistic people start losing jobs. Not because they can’t do the work. Not because they lack skill. Not because they’re difficult. But because the workplace is evaluating them on the wrong metrics. The theatre of work rewards the performance of competence, not competence itself. It rewards charisma over clarity, speed over accuracy, social ease over deep thinking, and emotional mimicry over emotional regulation. Autistic people excel at the actual work — the thinking, the building, the analyzing, the problem‑solving — but they struggle with the performance of work, which is what the system mistakenly treats as the real job.

This is why autistic people often get hired but struggle to stay. The résumé gets them in. The interview gets them through the door. But once they’re inside, they’re judged on a set of expectations that have nothing to do with their abilities and everything to do with their ability to perform neurotypical social behavior. They’re not failing the job. They’re failing the audition. And the tragedy is that the workplace loses the very people who could strengthen it — the ones who think deeply, who see patterns others miss, who bring clarity, integrity, and precision to their work.

The problem isn’t autistic people.
The problem is the theatre.
And until workplaces stop rewarding performance over output, autistic adults will continue to be hired for their skills and pushed out for their neurology.

---

Scored by Copilot. Conducted by Leslie Lanagan.